We Brits pride ourselves on being loyal — whether it’s the same café every morning, the supermarket we’ve trusted since the early 2000s, or the bank that’s held our wages for decades. But in 2025, when prices rise faster than wages and better deals are just a click away, it’s time to ask: is loyalty still rewarding us — or quietly costing us?
The Psychology Behind Loyalty
Loyalty feels good. Familiar faces, predictable service, and that comforting sense of being “known.” It’s part of our cultural DNA — and businesses know it. According to research, 91% of UK adults are part of at least one loyalty scheme, and over half say they’re more likely to buy from brands that offer points or perks.
It’s no surprise. In a world of financial uncertainty, those tiny wins — a free coffee, a discounted shop, a special offer — feel like rewards for our commitment. But scratch beneath the surface, and the question emerges: is loyalty always the smarter choice?
Where Loyalty Pays Off
Let’s give loyalty its due. In retail, it can genuinely work in your favour.
According to the UK’s Competition & Markets Authority (CMA), supermarket loyalty pricing is often legitimate, offering discounts averaging 17% to 25% off standard prices. If you’re a Tesco Clubcard or Nectar user, your big shop may be noticeably cheaper thanks to those savings.
For frequent shoppers or families managing a tight budget, loyalty points can add up to meaningful perks — think free meals, cheaper fuel, or cashback on everyday purchases. In these cases, staying loyal can pay off.
When Loyalty Becomes Habit — Not Value
Here’s the twist: loyalty isn’t always about love.
Around 70% of UK shoppers stay with a brand out of convenience, not genuine attachment. We’re creatures of habit — and businesses exploit that predictability.
That “I can’t be bothered to switch” mindset can cost hundreds a year. Energy tariffs, broadband deals, insurance renewals, and even mobile plans often reward new customers far more than loyal ones.
So while your loyalty points might save £20 a year, your loyalty penalty could be ten times that.
When Switching Wins — Big
Let’s talk about banking — one of the clearest examples of when switching pays.
In the past year, nearly a million people switched current accounts through the UK’s Current Account Switch Service. Why?
Because banks are offering cash bonuses of up to £310, free spending abroad, and modern mobile features that older banks can’t match.
In June 2025 alone, 88,000 people made the move, many citing poor service and outdated tech as their main reasons.
And it’s not just banks. Broadband providers, insurers, and even gyms are constantly running “new customer only” promotions. These aren’t just marketing tricks — they’re signs that loyalty might not be your best strategy anymore.
What Consumers Value Most: Trust or Price?
Interestingly, not everyone is chasing the best deal.
Four in ten customers stick with their bank for emotional reasons — trust, reliability, and service quality. And that’s fair. Good customer service can be worth paying for, especially in areas like healthcare or finance where peace of mind matters.
But here’s the challenge: when trust costs you more than it saves, it’s time for a review. Switching doesn’t have to mean starting from scratch — it just means re-evaluating whether your loyalty is still earning its keep.
The Hidden Cost of Staying Put
Businesses often rely on what’s known as the “loyalty penalty.” It’s a strategy where long-term customers end up paying higher prices than new ones. The CMA estimates that UK households lose around £4 billion a year collectively due to this effect — particularly across insurance, mortgages, and telecoms.
So, while loyalty schemes might hand you a £5 voucher, your renewal premiums could be quietly creeping up behind your back.
How to Know When It’s Time to Switch
Here’s a quick checklist to assess whether your loyalty is serving you or costing you:
✅ Stay loyal when:
- You consistently receive value-added perks or member-only prices.
- The service quality is exceptional and saves you time or stress.
- You’ve built up status (e.g. air miles, credit score benefits, or membership tiers).
🚫 Switch when:
- Introductory offers for new customers are significantly better.
- Renewal prices rise year-on-year without added value.
- You feel locked in out of convenience, not satisfaction.
A quick comparison can often reveal opportunities for hundreds of pounds in annual savings.
Real Stories of Smart Switching
Take “Sarah” from Oxfordshire, who switched energy suppliers after 10 years. Her reward? A £280 annual saving and a £50 cashback bonus.
Or “James,” who moved his current account and now enjoys fee-free spending abroad, saving him £12 a month on travel fees.
These aren’t rare cases — they’re the everyday wins of people who decided that loyalty had its limits.
How to Maximise the Value of Loyalty
Loyalty isn’t all bad — it just needs to be strategic.
Here’s how to make the most of it:
- Combine loyalty with price checks. Use apps like MoneySavingExpert or Which? Switch to compare deals before renewing anything.
- Stack rewards. Link your loyalty cards with cashback apps like Airtime Rewards or TopCashback for double benefits.
- Negotiate. Many providers offer retention deals if you call and threaten to switch.
- Track expiry dates. Don’t lose points through inactivity — set reminders.
- Know your worth. Your custom has value. Brands that truly value you will show it through fair pricing, not just perks.
The Loyalty vs Switching Debate in 2025
In 2025, the balance has shifted.
Loyalty still works in areas like retail, where consistent buying earns real rewards. But in finance, utilities, and digital services, switching is often the smarter move.
The winners are those who review regularly — who treat loyalty like a choice, not a habit.
The Verdict: Is Loyalty Costing You?
The truth? Sometimes yes.
Loyalty offers emotional comfort, but in a data-driven world where deals change weekly, blind loyalty can quietly drain your wallet.
Be loyal to good value, not just to brands.
Check, compare, and question. Because when it comes to your money — loyalty should always pay its way.
👉 Want more practical insights like this?
Stay ahead with the latest money-saving tips, local business news, and smart-living advice — sign up for our free newsletter today:
Subscribe here
FAQs About Loyalty vs Switching in the UK
1. Is it worth joining loyalty schemes in the UK?
Yes, especially for supermarkets and coffee chains where discounts are genuine. Just ensure you’re not spending more to chase points.
2. How much can I save by switching?
Depending on the category, UK consumers can save between £200 and £600 annually by switching banks, insurers, or energy suppliers.
3. Does switching affect my credit score?
Usually no, unless you apply for new credit. Switching services like broadband or energy has no impact on your credit file.
4. Why do companies reward new customers more than existing ones?
It’s a competitive tactic — new customers drive growth. But if enough people start switching, businesses are forced to reward loyalty better.
5. How often should I review my subscriptions and contracts?
At least once a year. Set reminders to check your bills, renewals, and direct debits.
